Northwestern China (Shaanxi)

Review

Dispute resolution
Anli Partners

The Xi'an office of Anli Partners focuses on high-end commercial legal services.

The director, Jingang Qu, is a key partner of the firm. His main areas of practice are commercial litigation and arbitration, as well as administrative law.

On the government and regulatory side, the firm has provided legal services to the Qinling Ecological and Environmental Protection Commission of Shaanxi province on the all-round remediation of nearly 400 hydropower stations in the northern and southern foothills of the Qinling Mountains. It also provided legal advice to the Shaanxi provincial government in hydropower remediation and railroad engineering construction.

DeHeng Law Offices

DeHeng Law Offices has two offices in Shaanxi province – in Xi'an and Xi'xian New Area. The firm’s Xi'xian New Area office, nominated by peers during the Benchmark Litigation China research interviews, focuses on commercial disputes and construction contract disputes.

Yuxin Yan, Qi Wang and Jun Xiao are the key names to note.

In 2023, the firm represented Yan'an University Xianyang Hospital in a dispute with Xianyang Shuangxing Real Estate Development Co. and Xianyang Langtian Jiacheng Real Estate Co. This case is the biggest case involving the largest amount of litigation since the establishment of Xianyang Hospital, and the total amount involved in this lawsuit and counterclaim is nearly Rmb200 million ($27.6 million). The biggest difficulty in the case is how to prove that the opposing parties constitutes a personality confusion, so that they can bear joint and several liabilities.

Additionally, the firm expanded its expertise by welcoming four new partners last year.

East & Concord Partners

The Xi'an office of East & Concord Partners focuses on high-end commercial legal services.

Senior partners Yan Wei, Hanyin Zheng and Guofeng Pang are the core figures of the Xi'an team.

During the research period, the team represented one of the largest securities companies in Shaanxi province in a pledged securities repurchase dispute. According to the firm, this was one of the most important enforcement proceedings between mainland China and Hong Kong in Shaanxi province, involving multiple provincial courts and multiple cases.

In addition, the firm represented a bank in a case of execution objection filed by the owners of real estate property. The litigation involved weighing the rights and interests of the bank, the developer and the owners of the real estate property. The stepping in of the owners of the real estate property made it difficult to realise the bank's priority right to receive the mortgage. Therefore, during the retrial, the court dismissed the objection of the owners of the real estate property and helped the client win the case.

Help Reaching Law Firm

Help Reaching Law Firm’s Xi'an office focuses on high-end commercial dispute resolution, construction and real estate legal services.

The firm's key partners are Liming Zhao, Juan Du, Daming Hao, Xitao Yang and Xianchun Lin.

During the research cycle, the firm represented the first case in Shaanxi province to systematically try a dispute over “format clauses”. The core point of the case is the identification of a “form contract”, but there is no clear standard in the current judicial practice. In response, the Help Reaching Law Firm’s team broke through the inertia and created a systematic understanding of contract provisions, and the decision further clarified and refined the criteria for determining form contracts in Chinese judicial practice, filling the judicial gap.

In addition, the firm has represented Xi'an Construction General Engineering Group in a series of construction contract disputes.

Hui Ye Law Firm

Hui Ye Law Firm's western office has long provided legal services for large state-owned enterprises and listed companies, and has rich experience in real estate and construction engineering, corporate and M&A, banking and finance, corporate compliance management and dispute resolution.

During the research period, the firm represented China Nuclear Industry No.2 Construction Corporation against Greenland Group Hefei Zifeng Real Estate Company in a construction contract dispute. The case considered more than 100 sets of properties and facilitated peace talks despite the huge commercial risks to Greenland Group. Other key cases also demonstrate Hui Ye's active presence in the Shaanxi legal market.

Major clients include China Nuclear Industry No. 2 Construction Group, Ping An of China Property Insurance, Xi'an Zheng Rong Real Estate, Jiangsu Jiangdu Construction Group, Guangzhou Fuli Real Estate Development Company and Xi'an Fuyi Real Estate Development Company.

In 2022, Hui Ye Law Firm recruited three partners for its Xi'an office: Pu Wang, Xuanye Pei and Jiayuan Li.

Jiaxuan Law Firm

Shaanxi Jiaxuan Law Firm is a full-service law firm based in Xi'an. The firm focuses on commercial matters and has offices in several locations in Shaanxi province. The firm's dispute resolution team includes more than 20 partners, and its practice areas cover corporate and commercial matters, construction and real estate, energy and minerals, etc.

During the research period, the firm represented Hitachi Elevator in a collection case regarding Evergrande Real Estate Group's Rmb600 million ($83 million) overdue commercial acceptances dispute. Evergrande Real Estate Group had long been paying Hitachi Elevator’s equipment and installation fees by electronic commercial acceptances. In 2021, Evergrande's broken capital chain triggered its going bankrupt, and a large number of electronic commercial acceptances issued to Hitachi Elevator by the group's project subsidiaries became overdue. According to Jiaxuan Law Firm, the number of cases under this collection is more than 1,400, involving 14 provinces, with significant impact.

In construction engineering and real estate, the firm helped clients resolve cases including disputes over land use right transfer contracts, construction contract disputes, and housing sale and purchase disputes, demonstrating the team's professionalism. For example, the firm represented Xi'an Chanba Development Group in a case involving a contract dispute over the transfer of land use rights between it and Shanghai Leunhua Real Estate, with deal value amounting to Rmb2.5 billion.

In 2023, the firm recruited three lawyers from universities, companies and local law firms.

Shaanxi Forever Law Firm

Founded in 1988, Shaanxi Forever Law Firm's dispute resolution practice is one of its traditional strengths.

During the research period, Forever Law Firm represented four investors whose properties had been damaged, filing a lawsuit against the listed company and the actual controller for misrepresentation. According to the firm, the case was the first securities support litigation case in Shaanxi. In another case, the team represented the defendant, an energy state-owned enterprise to confirm the validity of the contract signed between itself and the plaintiff, the supplier, under the financing trade and multi-layer transaction structure, and to claim tax losses based on the contractual agreement against the upstream coal supply counterclaim.

In addition, the firm has represented clients in resolving a number of complex debt matters and debt disputes.

Shaanxi Jindi Law Firm

Founded in 1995, Jindi Law Firm has provided legal services to many government agencies and state-owned enterprises.

Last year, the firm's dispute resolution team provided legal services in a dispute over an EPC contract for a photovoltaic power generation project. The construction party refused to pay for the project owing to its project quality. The project therefore required the commissioning of a judicial appraisal institution to make an appraisal of project quality. Photovoltaic project judicial appraisal in judicial practice is relatively rare, so the case is controversial on the qualification of the appraisal body and related norms have reference.

Representative clients include Xi'an Municipal Civil Affairs Bureau, Xi'an Construction General Engineering Group and Xi'an Municipal Finance Bureau.

V&T Law Firm

V&T Law Firm was founded in 1996, with 12 branches in China. The firm’s Xi’an office provides legal services in north-western China and dispute resolution is its key strength.

Yongpeng Wei is the managing partner of the office and also a leading lawyer of the firm.

In 2022, the office handled an executive disagreement between Shaanxi Longmen Iron and Steel Group, the biggest steel company in Shaanxi, and China Eastern Asset Management Corporation’s Shaanxi branch. This case is complicated as it involves many historical and complex issues such as the restructuring of state-owned enterprises 20 years ago, bank approval opinions, loan transfer management, corporate mergers and bankruptcies, government fraudulent policy benefits, financial asset disposal, and court judgment enforcement.

The main clients of the firm include China Life Insurance company (Shaanxi), Pacific Insurance (Shaanxi), Ping An Insurance Shaanxi Branch, China National Petroleum Corporation Changqing Oilfield Branch, Shaanxi Yijie Industrial Holding Group.

Client feedback

“Professional service and work attitude. Timely feedback.” – Commercial and transactions

“The firm's lawyers are professional, meticulous and the outcome of the case was as expected.” – Commercial and transactions

“Firstly, the result of the firm's representation is satisfactory; secondly, the firm is particularly professional and trustworthy in commercial disputes; and thirdly, the team of lawyers is particularly dedicated and responsible and works well with our company.” – Commercial and transactions

“Beijing V&T Law Firm’s Xi’an office has a professional team, which cooperates well with our company and provides the right service, and is able to respond to our company's legal needs in a timely and comprehensive manner, and has been our best partner for 15 years.” Commercial and transactions

“The firm is very careful and conscientious in representing cases, and all work is written, which is very much in line with the work habits of our state-owned enterprises. The team of this law firm is very modest and courteous, and works smoothly with our staff.” Commercial and transactions

“Beijing V&T Law Firm’s Xi’an office has a team of lawyers in the field of real estate, which understands the demands of our real estate company and provides considerate service with high response speed, and the results of the case are in line with expectations.” Commercial and transactions

“The lawyer team at this law firm is very professional and experienced in land transfer cases, and they had good communication and cooperation with us.” – Construction

“Beijing V&T Law Firm’s Xi’an office has a strong team of lawyers in the field of intellectual property, with high professionalism and good communication.” – Intellectual property

“Compliance services are deeply integrated into daily operation and management, and there has not been a single dispute case in 20 years.” – Government and regulatory

“The firm is very professional in the field of IP protection and financing, and has a strong team of lawyers.” – Government and regulatory

Yongpeng Wei

“Yongpeng Wei of Beijing V&T Law Firm’s Xi’an office cooperated well with us and provided professional services, and was our excellent partner.”

Yong Jia Xin Law Firm

Established in 2001, Shaanxi Yong Jia Xin Law Firm is a leading full-service legal firm in the western China region. With 13 specialised departments offering a wide range of legal services, the firm is dedicated to providing high-quality solutions exceeding client expectations. Boasting 352 skilled lawyers, including 55 partners and 204 lawyers, many of them graduates of prestigious law schools, Yong Jia Xin is a key player driving industry development and promoting the rule of law in western China and beyond.

Client feedback

“Good at representing in court and providing legal advice.” - Construction

Yuanyuan Yang

“Skilled in providing legal counselling, representing clients in litigation, offering legal advice, and conducting legal training.

Zhizheng Law Firm

Shaanxi Zhi Zheng Law Firm was established in 2001, with a focus on commercial disputes, and is well established in the fields of real estate and construction engineering, intellectual property, financial investment, compliance governance and foreign-related business.

The firm represented Shaanxi Electric Power Design Institute, which is under China Energy Construction Group, in a construction contract dispute with a photovoltaic power company in Longyuan. In addition, the firm has handled private lending disputes, financial non-performing debt transfer disputes, and equity transfer disputes.

Their main clients include China Development Bank, China Construction Bank, Agricultural Bank of China, China Communications Second Highway Engineering Bureau, China Construction Fifth Engineering Bureau, Shaanxi Public Security Department, Shaanxi Sports Bureau and Shaanxi Radio and TV Station.